Justices Alito and Thomas Slam SCOTUS Decision

In all my days, I never dreamed a conservative-leaning Supreme Court would issue a decision that on the surface, appears to be a soft-on-crime decision.

This would be especially true when the sentencing issue at the center of the case was related to gun violence.

Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito dissented on the opinion limiting federal reach for harsher sentences on crimes involving guns.

The Case

Justin Taylor was a marijuana dealer in Virginia during the early 2000s.

Taylor and several cohorts set up a buyer to rob, which resulted in one of the accomplices killing the buyer as the robbery occurred.

Taylor was eventually charged with “attempted Hobbs Act robbery,” which is considered a federal crime and carries a maximum sentence of 20 years.

In total, Taylor received a 30-year sentence because of the mandatory minimum sentence due to the federal statute of a firearm being used during a violent crime.

The majority ruled that the Hobbs Act is not a “crime of violence,” therefore, Taylor should have never received the additional 10 years.

Justice Neil Gorsuch, who has proven to be an absolute disaster of an appointment for Trump, stated, “Simply put, no element of attempted Hobbs Act requires proof that the defendant used, attempted to use, or threatened to use force.”

But, the defendant DID use a gun. Again, I am no legal expert, but the fact the Hobbs Act was committed with a firearm seems as though it should have come into play.

It raises the degree, or at least should, one would think.

Thomas went ballistic in his dissent, stating, “This holding exemplifies just how this Court’s ‘categorial approach’ has led the Federal Judiciary on a ‘journey Through the Looking Glass,’ during which we have found many ‘strange things.’

“Rather than continue this 30-year excursion into the absurd, I would hold Taylor accountable for what he actually did and uphold his conviction.”

Alito agreed, adding, “I agree with Justice Thomas that our cases involving 924(c)(3)(A) have veered off into fantasy land.

“But if the Court is going to disregard the real world and base its decisions in this area on a strict reading of the text, the ‘offense’ for which Taylor was convicted — attempted Hobbs Act robbery — meets the definition in 924(c)(3)(A).”

Perhaps the Hobbs Act needs to be amended to have two different categories, adding an additional classification for a violent crime with a firearm and possibly even a violent crime that results in death to ensure this never happens again.

This is one of the more bizarre opinions I have seen this court release, and I simply cannot believe three conservative justices agreed on this.

I have stated many times that I can live with a decision even if I don’t like it if is explained by the justices to have been properly made.

In this case, I think the Supreme Court has failed us miserably.

Source: Daily Caller

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn

9 Responses

  1. It Is Now Easier And More Realistic Than Ever Before In History To Make A Remarkable Income From The Comfort Of Your Own Home! HERE…….______ Visit Work AT Home

    1. It Is Now Easier And More Realistic Than Ever Before In History yhd To Make A Remarkable Income From The Comfort Of Your Own Home! HERE…….______ Visit profle

  2. complete time freedom and income are in front of you. This activity is just fantastic. Every individual can makes profits on-line with google without difficulty….,VISIT now___USA onlinejobs

  3. No boss, complete time freedom and income are in front of you. This activity is just fantastic. Every individual can makes profits on-line with google without difficulty….,VISIT now___BOOSTCASHapp

  4. It Is Now Easier And More Realistic Than Ever Before In History yhd To Make A Remarkable Income From The Comfort Of Your Own Home! HERE…….______ Visit profle

  5. Complete time freedom and income are in front of you. This activity is just fantastic. Every individual can makes

    profits on-line with google without difficulty……….VISIT now__________GOOGLE WORK

  6. No boss, complete time freedom and income are in front of you. This activity is just fantastic. Every individual can makes profits on-line with google without difficulty….,VISIT now___BOOSTCASHapp

  7. It Is Now Easier And More Realistic Than Ever Before In History yhd To Make A Remarkable Income From The Comfort Of Your Own Home! HERE…….______ Visit profle

  8. Complete time freedom and income are in front of you. This activity is just fantastic. Every individual snt09 can makes

    profits on-line with google without difficulty……….VISIT now__________GOOGLE WORK

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Sign Up for Daily Newsletter

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive breaking news updates emails from: Breaking News Digest, LLC, 299 Monroe Ave., Suite 2406, Roanoke, TX, 76262, US, https://www.Breaking News Digest.com/. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the link, found at the bottom of every email. 

PRESIDENTIAL NEWS

CONGRESSIONAL NEWS

GOP CHAIR TWEETS

In the last year, over 1 MILLION voters have switched to the Republican Party!

Thank you to all our grassroots volunteers for their hard work! #LeadRight

Today, a New York City court struck down the Democrats’ radical scheme that would allow over 800,000 non-citizens to vote in NYC elections.

This ruling is a huge victory for election integrity and the rule of law: American elections should be decided by American citizens. (1/2)

Instead of Biden visiting Saudi Arabia to beg for more oil, we should be unleashing energy production in America. #BidenGasHike

Load More...

MILITARY NEWS

VIDEOS & QUICK READS